Your Oyster Recipe of the Day: Lucky 12 Oysters. I read the ingredients for this one and thought, “Paprika, Parmesan and SUGAR? No thanks!” But I read on and Rosie Hawthorne at the Lucky 12 Tavern in Nags Head must be doing something right. Folks swear by these smoky, sweet, tangy, grilled oysters. Now, I’m ready to give them a try.