Your Oyster Recipe of the Day: Roasted Tomato Cocktail Sauce. Brandon Matzek at Kitchen Konfidence makes this cocktail sauce from scratch. We’re not talking ketchup! Matzek roasts Roma tomatoes then purees them with horseradish, lemon, Worcestershire, hot sauce and a little honey. He likes this glorious sauce with shrimp, but I can tell you, it’s fantastic with oysters, too.